Live-action film or animated film - when does what fit?
If you prefer to listen (in English)
When it comes to the production of educational- or information films, clients, producers, and educators face a crucial decision: should they choose animated film or traditional filmed film? The choice is particularly critical when the content to be presented is complicated, expensive, or difficult to film.
In this article, we will highlight the unique advantages and challenges of each format, focusing on situations where animated film may be the most suitable choice.
2D and 3D animated film - what is it?
Animated film, also known as an "animation", is a film technique where images are created to give the illusion of movement. It can be in the form of traditional hand-drawn (drawn film), computer-generated graphics, or a combination of the two. Animation has existed for over a hundred years and has evolved into a popular art form and entertainment medium worldwide. The two techniques most widely used in commercial film today are 2D or 3D animation.
2D animated film
2D animated film is one of the oldest forms of animation and has its roots in traditional cartoon films. In this type of animated films, characters, backgrounds, and objects are created on a two-dimensional surface. This is usually done by drawing each image or "frame" by hand or generating it digitally. The technique has evolved over time but retains its stylized and imaginative aesthetic, giving it a unique charm that many appreciate.
When it comes to software used to create 2D animations, Adobe Animate is one of the most popular. Previously known as Flash, Adobe Animate is used for both simple web animations and more complex film projects. Adobe After Effects is also an important tool, especially for adding special effects and composition to 2D animations. Adobe Illustrator and Photoshop are often used in the design phase to create and edit characters and backgrounds before they are animated.
In addition to traditional films and TV series, 2D animation has also found a niche in B2B and web marketing through the creation of so-called "explainer videos". These are short animated films that explain a company's product or service in a simple and easily understandable way. They are often used on company websites or in social media to quickly and effectively communicate complex information.
Examples of films and TV series where 2D animation is common include classic animated films, such as Disney's films like "Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs" and "The Lion King", as well as modern animated series like "Rick and Morty" and "The Simpsons". This form of animated films is also popular in other parts of the world, such as in Japanese anime with well-known works like "Spirited Away" and "My Neighbor Totoro". Regardless of cultural background, 2D animations continue to be a beloved and important part of the film and TV landscape.
3D animated film
3D animated film is a newer form of animation compared to its 2D counterpart. In 3D animation, characters and environments are created in a three-dimensional digital space, which gives a sense of depth and realism that is difficult to achieve with 2D techniques. This form has become increasingly popular since the late 20th century and is now used in everything from grand cinematic films to video games and virtual realities.
When it comes to software used for 3D animation, Autodesk Maya and Blender are two of the most prominent tools. Maya is known for its powerful functionality and is often used in large film productions, while Blender is a free alternative that has gained popularity for its flexibility and user-friendliness. Adobe After Effects is also used in 3D animations, particularly for composition and special effects, and programs like Adobe Photoshop and Illustrator can be used for texturing and design elements.
In addition to being used in the entertainment industry, 3D animation has also become increasingly popular in B2B and web marketing, especially for creating "explainer videos". Just like with 2D animation, these short films are designed to explain a company's product or service in a simple and easy-to-understand way, but with the extra dimension of depth and realism that 3D technology can offer.
Examples of films where 3D is commonly used include Pixar classics like "Toy Story" and "Finding Nemo", as well as other grand productions like "Avatar" and "Frozen". This technology has also become a standard in the video game industry, with titles like "The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild" and "Red Dead Redemption 2" that utilize the technology to create immersive worlds.
In summary, 3D animated film has not only revolutionized the film and TV industry, but has also found applications in marketing and other media forms, making it a versatile and indispensable part of today's digital landscape.
Benefits of animated film
Animation offers a range of benefits that make it particularly suitable for educational and informational projects. Below, we explore some of these benefits in detail:
Overcoming limitations: Filming certain subjects can be challenging due to location constraints or technical complexities. Animation eliminates these obstacles by being able to bring any concept to life without restrictions. This is particularly useful in educational contexts where it can be difficult to physically demonstrate certain phenomena or processes.
Cost-effective solution: Traditional film production requires extensive planning and resources, which can strain budgets. With an efficient workflow and in-house capabilities, you can enjoy high-quality animations at competitive prices. No more budget overruns while delivering exceptional results!
Unleash creativity: Animated videos open up endless creative possibilities. This means you have full control over how characters interact, capture attention, and convey complex ideas. By utilizing this flexibility, your message becomes even more impactful and memorable.
Visualize abstract concepts: Educational content often involves explanations of intricate theories. Animations make it easier than ever before. Its ability to break down complicated subjects makes it easier for viewers to quickly understand information, making it easier to grasp difficult-to-understand concepts.
Time Efficiency: Time plays a crucial role in every project. Animation accelerates the production process. With well-established processes, a dedicated team, and state-of-the-art equipment, fast delivery is ensured without compromising quality. Say goodbye to long waiting times; get ready for faster delivery times!
Animated films offer a range of benefits that make them an excellent choice for educational and informational films. From overcoming physical and budgetary limitations to unlocking creative possibilities and streamlining production, animation is a powerful tool for conveying complex information in an accessible and engaging way.
Disadvantages of animated film
Despite the many benefits of animation, there are also certain limitations and challenges that can affect its effectiveness in educational and informational environments. Here are some of these:
Lack of Realism: Animation can sometimes lack the realism that live-action film offers. This can be a disadvantage when trying to convey subjects that require a more realistic representation to be credible or effective.
Cost and Time Consumption for High-Quality Animation: While animation can be cost-effective for some projects, high-quality animation can be both time-consuming and expensive. Specialized animation tools and expertise can also add to the costs.
Technical Limitations: Animation requires technical expertise and access to specialized software. If you don't have the necessary resources or competencies, this can be a significant disadvantage.
Risk of Exaggeration or Oversimplification: The creative freedom in animation can sometimes lead to exaggeration or oversimplification of complex subjects. This can result in important information being lost or misunderstood.
Target group limitations:
Animated film offers many benefits, but it is essential to carefully consider its potential drawbacks in the context of your specific project. From costs and technical limitations to risks of exaggeration and target group limitations, it is crucial to weigh the pros and cons before making a decision to use animation in educational and informational films.
Benefits of filmed film
Filmed film, or live-action, has its own unique benefits that make it a powerful tool in educational and informational environments. Here are a few of these:
Realism and Authenticity: One of the biggest advantages of filmed video is its ability to convey realism. This can be particularly important in educational contexts where a realistic representation can reinforce the message and make it more convincing.
Human Interaction and Emotions: Live-action film can capture nuances in human interaction and emotions in a way that is difficult to achieve with animation. This can be valuable when trying to convey complex human relationships or emotional aspects of a subject.
No Technical Expertise Required: Unlike animation, which often requires specialized software and technical knowledge, filmed video can often be produced with simpler means. This makes it accessible to a wider group of content creators.
Direct and Immediate: Filmed video can be produced quickly and often distributed almost immediately after recording. This can be an advantage in educational contexts where time-sensitive information needs to be conveyed.
Opportunity for In-Depth Interviews and Reporting: Live-action film makes it possible to include interviews and reports that can provide depth and context to the subject being addressed. This can be difficult to achieve with animation without losing authenticity.
Filmed video offers a range of benefits that make it an effective tool in educational and informational projects. From its ability to convey realism and emotions to its accessibility and speed, live-action has its own unique strengths that complement the benefits that animation can also offer. As always, it is essential to carefully consider which medium best suits your specific project and goals.
Disadvantages of filmed film
Even if filmed film has many advantages, there are also challenges and limitations that can affect its effectiveness in educational and informational environments. Here are a few of these:
Logistical and Economic Limitations: Filmed video can often be expensive and logistically complicated to produce. It can require everything from actors and film crew to locations and permits, which can be costly and time-consuming.
Limitations in Creative Freedom: Unlike animation, where almost everything is possible, filmed video has physical and practical limitations. This can be a disadvantage when trying to visualize abstract or complex concepts.
Sensitivity to Errors and Mistakes: Since filmed video often involves real people and environments, there is a greater risk of unforeseen errors or mistakes that can affect the production's quality or credibility.
Time pressure: Unlike animation, where elements can be adjusted and refined over time, filmed footage can be time-sensitive. This can be a disadvantage if you need to make changes or adjustments after filming has been completed.
Target audience limitations: Filmed footage can sometimes be less universally appealing than animation, particularly for younger target audiences or international audiences who may have difficulty relating to cultural or ethnic specific elements in the film.
While filmed footage offers many advantages, including realism and the ability to convey human emotions, it is essential to be aware of its limitations and challenges. From logistical and financial obstacles to limitations in creative freedom and time pressure, it is crucial to carefully consider these aspects when choosing the most suitable medium for your educational or informational project.
Checklist for choosing between animated and live-action film
Choosing the right format for your educational or informational film can be a complex process with many variables to consider. This checklist is designed to help you quickly and systematically evaluate the most important factors that can influence your decision.
Follow the steps below to use the checklist:
General
Animated Film vs. Live-Action Film
Discussion: If possible, discuss the checklist with your team, producers, or other stakeholders. Other perspectives can provide valuable additional insights.
Conclusion: After going through the checklist, weigh the checked points to determine which format seems most suitable for your project.
By using this checklist, you can make a more informed choice and ensure that you utilize the unique benefits of the format you choose.
General
What is the purpose of the film? (Education, information, marketing, etc.)
What target audience is the film aimed at?
What is the budget for the project?
How much time do you have available for production?
Animated Film
Is it important to visualize complex or abstract concepts?
If yes, animation may be more suitable.
Is it difficult or expensive to film what you need in reality?
If yes, animation can be a cost-effective solution.
Are creative freedom and stylization important aspects of the project?
If yes, animation offers more creative possibilities.
Do you have access to the technical resources and expertise required for animation?
If not, it may be a limitation.
Live-Action Film
Is realism and authenticity important for the project?
If yes, live-action film may be more suitable.
Are human interaction and emotions central elements?
If yes, live-action film can capture this more effectively.
Do you have access to the locations, actors, and resources required for filming?
If not, it may be a limitation.
Is time-sensitive information or fast production a priority?
If yes, live-action film can be produced and distributed faster.
Combination of live-action film and animation may become the best "animated films"
After exploring the unique benefits and challenges of both animated and live-action film, it is worth noting that these two formats do not always have to be mutually exclusive. In some cases, a combination of the two can offer a "best of both worlds" solution that leverages the strengths of each format.
For example, animation can be used to visualize complex concepts or abstract ideas within a live-action film, where realism and human interaction are also important. This can be particularly useful in educational contexts, where a realistic representation can be enhanced and complemented with animated illustrations or diagrams.
On the marketing side, a filmed product video can be complemented with animated graphic elements to clarify the product's features or benefits. This creates a richer, more engaging experience that can be both informative and entertaining.
Technology has made it increasingly easy to integrate these two formats, and many modern tools, such as Adobe After Effects, now offer the ability to combine live-action and animated elements seamlessly.
So before you make your final choice, consider the possibility of using both animated and filmed video in your project. It can prove to be a "match made in heaven" that gives you the best of both worlds, and makes your message even more effective and memorable.
Do you need help?
If you're facing the choice between animated and live-action film for your next educational or informational project, why not leverage expertise? At Multiproduktion, our studio has the experience and tools to help you make the best possible choice. Whether you're interested in a pure animated film, a live-action production, or an exciting combination of both, we can offer tailored solutions that meet your unique needs and goals.
Don't hesitate to contact us for a free consultation. We look forward to helping you bring your vision to life and creating a film that not only reaches your target audience but also leaves a lasting impression.